Systemic Failure

It's rare for me to say this, but: man I'm glad I didn't go to the rugby (Tahs vs Crusaders) last night. Just watching it on TV (glorious HD!) was frustrating enough, without having to travel back from Homebush.

Kurtley Beale has been getting his fair share of criticism from the various snipers out there -- some of it is deserved, but the problems for the Tahs are more far-reaching than just the inexperience/confidence of the player at pivot.

The most frustrating flaws I saw last night were the lack of kick chase and the the isolation of a ball runner at the breakdown after they'd made a big break. And then our efforts vs the Crusaders at rucking and counter-rucking. These are all basics, and the Crusaders did them very well while we constantly did this poorly. It makes me ponder whether there is a lack of match fitness on our part -- it certainly looked to me like there was a bit of fatigue setting in soon after the second half started.

Where the Waratahs have at least shown discipline in the past in lieu of being opportunistic in contesting at the rucks or kick chase, last night they were neither. (In fact, for all the times the Crusaders were setting us for overlap, I was surprised we were stung so little...) I was also astounded at our lineout losses; the throws did not seem poor -- it looked to me that the communication and efforts of the jumper were more the issue.

None of this should be put on Kurtley.

What I didn't like from Kurtley was the quality of his passing; if you are going to play at first receiver you cannot be hurling hospital passes -- occasionally when Norton Knight came up he was doing the same thing.

If I was head coach Chris Hickey, as much as I love Tom Carter's solid game, I'd be tempted to make a change to play Halangahu at 10 and Tahu at 12. Halangahu seems to be a better decision maker, and Tahu is too good to be only playing what seems like half an hour a game. I'd try and stick to this combination for a couple of games.

But those changes won't really matter if the Tahs don't making broader improvements with the fundamentals.